Resurrecting this topic, because I just saw the film today (it came out here in the UK last Friday).
Overall, I
really enjoyed it. Great cast (the only other thing I've seen Armie Hammer in is Mirror Mirror, which wasn't particularly brilliant, but I thought he did a
wonderful job), a lot of incredible action set-pieces, and you could really
see every dollar of the budget on screen. The final action sequence, when
that music keyed up, was jaw-droppingly amazing.
That said, it wasn't flawless.
The biggest problem for me was actually the marketing. All the trailers I've seen really pushed this film as a family-friendly fun-filled romp, and it's not, to be honest. Yes, there's action and humour and adventure. But there's also some
really dark scenes and themes (cannibalism, hurting children, genocide, to name a few), much more so than the Pirates franchise, and while the humour is definitely there, it's not as much a comedy as the trailers made it out to be. It's the kind of film that could potentially be a little too intense for younger children, but the marketing might alienate older viewers. I think the advertising department really took the wrong tack.
Other than that, I think the narrative device didn't really work as well as it did for Princess Bride (it's kind of a bummer to know Tonto winds up all alone and disorientated) and it needed
far more Red. I hope we can add her NPC to our toy boxes, because she will be in every single one I make!
But, yes, I did like it a
lot, just so this doesn't look entirely negative or anything. I think it'll be even
more enjoyable the second time around, when the tone and content doesn't take me quite so much by surprise, and I can't wait for the playset to arrive. And I'll definitely be getting this on Blu-Ray as soon as it's released!